Why People Drive to New Paris for a Gluten Free Bakery

A mom with a baby who can’t have dairy orders a smash cake and gets a first birthday cake she doesn’t have to worry about. A carb conscious customer walks in expecting to find one keto option and leaves with a birthday cake. Someone tastes a raspberry pastry and likes it so much she has an order sent to Texas.

These are all real customers, and they are the reason Baked by Vi holds a 4.9 star rating across 61 Google reviews (as of November 9, 2026). Here is what they’ve told us, in their own words.

People finally get to relax

Emma Anderson eats gluten free and called the shop “truly a hidden gem,” saying it satisfies the sweet treats she misses. Sophia Jenkins wrote that her baby can’t have dairy, that the smash cake she ordered was cute and delicious, and that there were plenty of dairy free options. Aleia Pompey, a self-described picky eater, said she would give more than five stars if she could.

Dale Miller found Vi at a local farmers’ market and then stopped by the shop. He wrote that she is “very transparent” about ingredients, so people with many different sensitivities can find something that works.

Everyone at the table can eat

Bridget Russo is very carb conscious. She was delighted to find so many keto options and ordered a 6 inch keto cake for her birthday. KW called Baked by Vi the “best bakery possibly ever,” praising a menu that covers gluten free, paleo, keto and vegan eating, including the raspberry rose scones.

It’s about Vi, too

Reviewers talk about her as much as the food. Ash described the shop as an “adorable little bakery with the sweetest owner.” Jan Longcor called it a “small town friendly cafe.” Elizabeth Howard wrote that she and her husband often stop for lunch while picking up gluten free bread. Eyob Zeleke, a regular, said it’s the best in Michiana for healthy eating, and he orders the breakfast egg sandwich with avocado.

Worth the drive

Christine Boyle’s order to Texas isn’t the only long-distance story. Lakes East magazine reported that customers have come from as far as Columbia City, Chicago, West Lafayette, Aurora, Wabash and Michigan.

How it all began

That article, “Something for Everyone,” was written by Amy Lant-Wenger for our first anniversary, and it tells Vi’s story better than a summary can. We’d encourage you to read it in full.

In brief, Vi began baking at home and started selling at the Goshen Farmers’ Market in 2018. Custom orders soon outgrew her kitchen, and in the fall of 2022 she opened the shop at 68458 Main Street in historic downtown New Paris. The article also shares a moment from those market days. A boy mentioned he had never eaten a doughnut because of food allergies, and Vi had one he could safely try. According to the article, he was moved to tears, along with several people watching.

The article also captures how Vi approaches every customer. In it, she says, “I love to be a part of the journey.” That means asking what you need, reading labels carefully, and being upfront about what goes into every item.

Come see for yourself

Baked by Vi is a dedicated gluten free bakery and cafe, with options that are also dairy free, keto, paleo and vegan. Dine in, grab coffee and a scone to go, or order a cake for a birthday that matters. If you have questions about ingredients or allergies, ask. Vi would much rather talk it through than have you guess.

Visit us at 68458 Main Street, New Paris, Indiana. Visit our site any time for current hours, and call or email if you want to plan an order ahead.


Sources

Previous
Previous

[Recipe Name]